By “who” here, I mean which electronics - I’ve picked up the developer habit of at least sometimes calling them “he” or “this guy” (yes, of course they’re male. Here’s the official joke).
Any trip of any kind gets at least a cellphone, 1 PDA (just in case I need a quick game while I’m stuck waiting for something) and my mp3 player. More and more, the pedometer comes along - not only do I like to “get credit” for how much I’m walking, it also has a built-in clock, and since I don’t wear a watch (or always carry the cellphone if I’m just walking around for exercise) that’s very handy. And of course if I’m on a business trip, I also bring a laptop for taking notes and checking email, and usually at least 2 PDAs, just because my business trips are PDA related.
But now that we have this UMPC, I’m seriously considering how many other devices it could replace. Certainly I don’t need the UMPC and the laptop, and the UMPC is a lot lighter. It’s not as easy to use, but it’s enough more portable that it would definitely be worth considering. But then Marc mentioned getting a portable DVD drive for it and then it suddenly got much more attractive.
I’d like to be able to watch movies on planes - I can’t read comfortably, and don’t handle just sitting very well at all. We have a portable media player, but between trying to see that small a screen and the hassle of setting it up with anything I’d want to see, I never bothered with it. But if I can plug a DVD drive into the UMPC and just bring some DVDs to watch on the plane, then plug a keyboard into it to take notes in the conference, it becomes a very attractive option.
Then I don’t need a PDA, because I can just as easily whip out the UMPC (screen part only) to play games when I want to. And I don’t need the MP3 player if I can watch DVDs on the plane instead of listening to books.
While a UMPC plus keyboard plus DVD drive probably isn’t quite as light as some - less geeky - people travel, it’s a definite improvement over a laptop plus mp3 player plus PDA. And while right now, I have the luxury of choosing from all the devices we have available for any given trip, I could easily see that if I didn’t, and had to make a choice of what to buy, a UMPC would have a lot going for it. Particularly in a year or so when the battery life is better.
I’m seeing a lot of potential in the UMPCs. I don’t think I’ll take it to Denver this week, but I bet it goes with me on the next trip.
I’m Lee, part of the support team, and if you call or email for tech support you will probably get Kevin before you get me, unless you are a bulk-purchaser or one of a select bunch of resellers.
I have been doing tech support of one variety or another for about 15 years, nearly five of those here at Ilium Software. It truly is a great place to work; it’s nice to be around people who are caring and honest, and really believe in what they are doing.
I, too, am a big fan of our software, especially ListPro and eWallet. I use them every day, both at work and home, and wonder how I ever managed without them. Both travel everywhere with me on my Treo 650; it’s so nice to have my information at my fingertips! I save a ton of time by filtering my grocery list to only show the items I need, and then sort it by aisle. Then I print it out and check it off in the store (I really don’t have enough hands to wrangle two active kids, a grocery cart, *and* my Palm – and besides my kids will ask endlessly “Mom, can I play a game on your Palm now?” Out of sight, out of mind). One trip through the store and I’m done. No backtracking to a missed item (this is a really good thing – see previous statement about two active kids…).
Also, since I am calendar-challenged (write it on the calendar and promptly forget it), I use a running list of appointments, events, reminders, etc. in ListPro. Since I am constantly referring to it for one reason or another, I don’t miss appointments anymore. When an event is past, I check it off to make it hidden, but I can easily look back and say “When was that?”.
Did someone encourage me to write about our software? No. Do I recommend it to friends, and even people I don’t know? Yup. It’s good stuff, and it just works.
Actually, they’re not so tiny. The Samsung Q1 for example has a 800x480 screen, which seems small but it’s adequate. Anyone who remembers (or still uses!) the Handheld PC devices will recognize that as a similar format to the famous 640x240 screen, but with more wide and twice the tall.
The problem was, we didn’t have a UMPC to play with so I didn’t have any real-life experience. Well, now we do, and I’ve played with it.
In short, my verdict is: Needs Work. This is on a scale of, “Dismal Failure” to “Sliced Bread”. For a first-revision device in a ’new field’, Needs Work seems to be a pretty decent assessment. Certainly not a Dismal Failure.
For more details, a quick review, and a picture, read on.
If you have no idea what a Samsung Q1 is, this is it:
That’s a 7" diagonal touch-sensitive screen, a 900MHz Intel Celeron M processor, 512MB of ram, a 30GB hard drive, and Windows XP Tablet Edition.
The really good:
Touch Sensitive Screen: having used our office Acer TravelMate Tablet PC, the touch screen is really nice. Tablet PCs use RF screens that work like graphics digitizer tablets, which can be aggravating as the mouse cursor won’t end up right underneath the tip of the pen. With a UMPC, you touch the screen and that’s where the cursor goes.
Small: PDA’s are pocket-sized, laptops are lap-sized, while the Q1 is “messenger-bag sized”. If I was still a student, I wouldn’t hesitate to toss this thing into my bag and haul it everywhere with me. It weighs less than a medium-sized textbook.
Windows XP: If you sit around saying, “Gee, I wish I had a portable computer smaller than a laptop but ran th same software as my desktop PC!”, UMPCs like the Q1 are probably just the ticket. The Q1 will run the same software your desktop PC will.
The not-so good:
Touch Sensitive Screen: I don’t think that this is necessarily a problem with the Q… the Tablet PC OS seems to be designed to be used with an RF mouse or pen in mind. When you touch the screen, the cursor is moved to that location instantly and registers as if you clicked. This makes clicking and dragging items a pain sometimes, since it’s hard to position the cursor exactly when it won’t move until you touch the screen to click.
Battery life: You only get about 2 hours of battery life.
Portrait mode: You can flip the screen into portrait mode, which is nice. It also makes the Q1 much easier to hold with one hand this way. However, Windows XP’s taskbar isn’t really made to look good when it is 480 pixels wide, and webpages may get squashed to a skinny column of text.
Width: Not the screen, but the whole Q1. The device itself is 10 inches wide, which means holding it with one hand in landscape orientation puts a lot of levered force on your wrist and becomes tiring
The bad:
Text entry: If you’re a touch-typist, you will sorely miss a built-in keyboard of some type. If you hunt and peck and are a huge fan of writing on your PDA, you might be fine. I found entering in text with the standard tablet PC tools to be very annoying. I’m sure this may change if I use the device for a long time, but having a hardware keyboard right there would present zero learning curve.
The Q1 features a program called DialKeys, which splits a QWERTY keyboard in half and attaches the keys in quarter-circles centered at the lower left and lower right corner, so your thumbs can press the keys. I found this to be awkward and intuitive at the same time, and tended not to use it. There are other ways of doing text entry - the venerable Fitaly is available for Tablet PCs, as are several other options.
So how does the screen measure up?
Enough stuff on the screen at once, minimal squinting, not quite enough height. The big shortcoming here is vertical space - dialog boxes may not fit on the screen vertically and you’re left trying to figure out how to see the bottom of the box, not to mention all the scrolling up and down. [ I’m not the only one who thinks this.] The extra 120 pixels of 800x600 would go a long way, as it’s the default recommended resolution for standard Windows XP and many web designers still make sites to be functional at 800 pixels across without scrolling.
Unlike the VGA Pocket PCs (and Palms), the Q1 doesn’t change the DPI from a standard PC display, so you can see quite a bit of information despite the shortcomings. A direct comparison would be the old 640x240 screens on Handheld PCs and the Q1 just blows them away. If you’re going to be working with spreadsheets and have a choice between a VGA Pocket PC and a Q1, you’d probably pick the Q1 hands down.
Bear in mind this is a first-revision device, and Microsoft is already planning the next big revision, and some of the shortcomings (like battery life) are things that all companies struggle with.
Would I buy one? No - I just don’t have the money and I’m usually either here at work or at home, not out on the go as a “Mobile Professional”. If I had the disposable income, I’d snap one up for couch-surfing.
Oh, and our software - eWallet, ListPro, and KeepTrack - looks pretty good on it!
Hi, I’m Julie. I’ve been working at Ilium Software since last September, and I help work on the website and marketing end of things. I also help answer the phones when everyone in support gets swamped. So, if any out there ever calls and gets me, you might not get technical help right away, but I am great at taking messages!
Besides working on the web site here, I am still going to school, online, for a degree in web development, so I am pretty much in front of a computer screen either here or at home, about 12 hours a day. Of course, I’m not complaining, really – I’m glad that there is such a thing as online school. I don’t know if I would be able to work here and attend a traditional college – there just isn’t much flexibility in on-site schools, but the Internet is always open.
I have to admit, before I started working at Ilium Software, I didn’t know much at all about PDAs. I mean, I’d heard about them, seen commercials and ads, but I couldn’t have told you the difference between a Pocket PC and a Palm handheld to save my life. Of course, it’s not like they always make it easy out there, as in the new Palm Treo 700w Smartphone, which actually runs a Pocket PC operating system. I’m sure I’m not the only person who’s ever been confused by handheld devices. So I’m really glad that I’m starting to understand more about mobile devices and that I am able to use them when I need to around here – the world is definitely becoming more mobile, and wireless, and all those other technological-type adjectives.
I was reading an article on the Just Another Mobile Monday blog about students in a New Jersey high school who are going to be issued tablet PCs in the Fall, and man! if that’s not proof right there about how important it’s becoming to understand how to live in a technological world. When I was in high school, I only had one or two teachers who wouldn’t accept reports that weren’t typed – the rest still took handwritten work. In my house, we had a Brother word processor with this tiny screen that displayed gold text on a black background only, and I thought I was so cool when I used that thing to type stuff up! I can’t even imagine using a school-issued tablet PC with Internet access to turn in my work and talk to my teachers. Not going to be very good news for those kids who don’t like to turn in their work – no more excuses, like the article said.
So, that’s me. Probably one of the least tech-savvy people who happened to ever stumble into this line of work, but I’m getting better.
I liked Kevin’s introduction so much that I’m going to encourage everyone else here to write one. Which I’m pretty sure means I should do one first.
I’m Ellen, one of the people who started Ilium Software, back in 1997. I’ve met some of the people who are reading this - many of the people who run the PDA and mobile related websites, as well as many other developers and even quite a few users - at various conferences and events over the years. I’ve also talked to a number of users (fewer in recent years, but still keep my hand in a little) over the phone and by email. And of course I’ve seen many companies and individuals drop out of mobile software completely. Like people say about old age, it’s definitely not for sissies.
If companies reflect the personalities of the people who started them, I guess Ilium Software reflects mine to a large extent. Certainly our emphasis on providing really good support is a direct result of my frustration with the very bad support I’ve received from too many companies over the years. I don’t accept bad support from anyone (at least not more than once), and as long as I’m in control, we won’t provide it.
Like Kevin, I use our software all the time, because I like what it does and how it works. This probably isn’t coincidence - I designed or at least specified much of it. But because my background isn’t in tech, I think (or at least hope) that I have more of an end-user perspective than other people might.
I don’t want to put up a picture of myself (like many people, I hate pictures of myself), and don’t have quite the collection of handhelds that Kevin does, so will instead put up my bulletin board. Since I’m writing about my personality, I think it’s a pretty good illustration.
The buttons say:
Trust me; I’m a professional
This is just my corporate image
If you’re not outraged, you’re not paying attention
Making the world safe for musical comedy
I am a Jewish American Princess; please buy me a Tab
The bumper stickers say:
Oh No, Not Another Learning Experience
Don’t make me release the flying monkeys
The cartoons are about being impatient, easily distracted, grown-up, and short. I’d show pictures of them, but I think that’s a violation of their intellectual property, which, as a software developer, I’m of course very sensitive to.
The picture is the guys on Sports Night (TV series of a few years ago), in their shirts, ties and boxer shorts.
I really love those parenthetical titles! The software industry - and in fact anyone who wants to sell something - is driven by either addressing customer needs and wants, or trying to invent a need/want so that customers will buy a product.
Push email is a good example. Do you need it? Maybe. Does everyone need it? Probably not. Do you want it? Maybe. Do you need it because you want it, or because your job depends on you actually being able to respond to an email within one minute even when you’re taking a pit stop? That depends entirely on you and your boss. Or do you want it because someone says, “Push email is big!” [Incidentally, here’s an article about why Push Email may not be so great over at Modern Nomads that touches on the issue of want vs need.]
This post is about screen resolution. Screen resolution has gone up fairly steadily over the years. My parents’ first computer had a 15" CRT monitor that cost $500 and could just barely handle displaying 1280x1024 resolution at eye-melting 60hz. Now, a 19" CRT that can easily do the same at readable 85hz costs $90 from OfficeMAX. The 17" LCD I’m using right now can easily support that resolution natively and cost about $200 - a similar one I just sold that I’d purchased in May of 2004 was $440. When my parents bought their first computer, the whopping 30" Apple Cinema Display was completely unheard of as something a mortal could purchase, but now Dell has equivalently-sized displays that aren’t so crazy. Television screens used to be the size of a small toaster - today, even a college student can afford a plasma display (your college student may vary.)
We want bigger, we can have bigger, so we get bigger. What about PDAs? Instead of getting bigger, we want smaller. Witness the relative explosion of the Smartphone market as opposed to the palm-sized handhelds of various flavors. Smartphone devices are pretty cool any way you slice them - except for one thing.
The screen is really small! All Windows Mobile 5 Smartphones use ‘QVGA’ displays, 320x240 pixels. However, these phones don’t display any more data than the previous 176x220 displays - they just make it look prettier with more pixels. The same goes for VGA Pocket PCs, or high-resolution Palm-powered handhelds - a 640x480 Dell Axim X51V can’t display any more data on the screen than the 320x240 Axim X5 could, nor can my Treo 650 put anything more on its 320x320 screen than the original Palm could with its 160x160 screen.
It really is possible to cram more data on the screen - you just use a smaller font size. We get requests all the time - especially for ListPro - to add ‘high resolution’ support to our applications. The way I’ve seen this done, the screen font size is halved. My DateBk6 program on my Treo 650 can do this easily. The problem is… I can’t do it. I’m young, and even though I am nearly legally blind without my glasses, I can see pretty well with them on. That doesn’t make reading characters any easier when they’re as big as this period –> . [For a look at how this works out on ultra-portable and UMPCs, take a look at this blog post by JKOntherun]
We want smaller and bigger at the same time - smaller dimensions, higher resolutions. “QVGA is too small! It’s too ugly low-res!! Why would I want a Treo 700w when the screen is only 240x240! I want more pixels! More pixels! 10 megapixel cameras! XGA Pocket PCs!
Do people really need these tiny screens? Do people really want them? Are they being told they want them by marketing? Are they assuming that more pixels is better? Tech people aren’t immune to ‘more is better’ - I bought my new digital camera partly because it was just $20 more to get 7.1 instead of 6MP! Why get a regular value meal when you can biggie size it (disclaimer: biggie sizing no longer exists at Wendy’s) for just 40 cents more? Why get an Axim X51 (320x24) when you can get the X51V (640x480, four times as many pixels) for less than $100 more?
So what do we as a company do? Do we spend a lot of time adding a feature to our software just to make it more flexible, giving people the option to squint at their 2.5” screen to see 300 lines of text instead of 150 (disclaimer: I made that number up.) Do we have to climb on that bandwagon in order to make sure we stay relevant? Or do we try to make software that is easily used on a 2.5" screen by people with average fingers and average eyeballs?
I certainly don’t have the answer. I would love to be able to see more of my shopping list in ListPro on my Palm, but I don’t think I’d be happy trying to check off “Get eye exam” using my thumbnail when my nail’s thicker than the item I’m trying to poke on the screen. Maybe the ideal solution is a compromise - give people all their data when they want it, and readable data when they need it.